Demand Diversity: 100-Unit Apartment Block -- Same Building, 4 Different Maximum Demands

Scenario: A 100-unit all-electric apartment building with 8kW per unit plus 50kW of common services. Total installed load: 850kW. Four standards apply their diversity factors. One says you need a 500kVA transformer. Another says 800kVA. The same building, the same tenants, the same appliances -- and a 300kVA gap that translates to a six-figure cost difference.

---

The Scenario

A new residential tower development:

• 100 apartments, each with:
  • 2kW lighting and small power
  • 2kW cooking (electric oven + hob)
  • 2kW hot water (electric storage or instant)
  • 1kW air conditioning
  • 1kW general (washing machine, dryer, miscellaneous)
  • Total per unit: 8kW
• Common services: 50kW
  • 2 lifts: 15kW each = 30kW
  • Corridor and car park lighting: 10kW
  • Fire systems and ventilation: 10kW
• Supply: 400V three-phase
• No gas supply -- all electric building
• Total installed load: 100 x 8kW + 50kW = 850kW

Nobody designs the supply for 850kW. The question is: what fraction of that installed load will occur simultaneously at peak? This is where the standards diverge dramatically.

---

Standard-by-Standard Calculation

AS/NZS 3000:2018 (Table C1)

AS/NZS 3000, Appendix C, Table C1 provides diversity factors for residential buildings based on the number of dwelling units.

Method: Table C1 diversified maximum demand

For all-electric dwellings, Table C1 (interpolated for 100 units):

Note: These values are based on extensive Australian utility metering data (Energy Networks Australia / Ergon / Ausgrid studies). The ADMD decreases as the number of units increases because statistical averaging smooths out individual peaks.

Calculation:

Diversified dwelling demand = 100 units x 3.5 kVA = 350 kVA

Common services (no diversity applied to essential services):
  Lifts: 30kW x 0.8 pf x 1.0 diversity = 37.5 kVA
  Lighting: 10kW x 0.9 pf = 11.1 kVA
  Fire/ventilation: 10kW x 0.85 pf = 11.8 kVA
  Common services total = 60.4 kVA

Total maximum demand = 350 + 60.4 = 410.4 kVA

AS/NZS transformer selection: 500 kVA (next standard size above 410 kVA)

Effective diversity factor for dwellings: 350 / 800 = 43.8%

---

BS 7671:2018+A2 / IET Guidance Note 1 (Table 1A/1B)

BS 7671 itself deliberately does not provide a prescriptive diversity table for multiple dwellings. The standard's philosophy is that diversity assessment is an engineering judgment based on the specific building. However, supplementary guidance documents are widely used:

• ACE Report 114 (Association of Consulting Engineers, now superseded)
• IET Guidance Note 1 (Selection and Erection)
• CIBSE Guide K (Electricity in Buildings)
• Electricity Safety, Quality and Continuity Regulations (ESQCR) -- UK DNO requirements

The widely used formula from ACE 114 (and adopted by most UK Distribution Network Operators):

Method: After Diversity Maximum Demand (ADMD) per unit

For all-electric dwellings, the typical UK ADMD values:

Note: UK DNOs (e.g., UK Power Networks, Western Power Distribution) publish their own ADMD tables, which vary by region and climate. The values above are typical for southeast England.

Calculation:

Diversified dwelling demand = 100 units x 2.5 kVA = 250 kVA

Common services = 60.4 kVA (same as above)

Total maximum demand = 250 + 60.4 = 310.4 kVA

BS 7671 / UK DNO transformer selection: 315 kVA (standard UK transformer size)

Effective diversity factor for dwellings: 250 / 800 = 31.3%

This is notably lower than AS/NZS. The UK values reflect smaller average dwelling sizes, lower cooling loads (temperate climate), and extensive historical metering data from a dense urban population.

---

NEC / NFPA 70:2023 (Article 220.84 -- Optional Method)

NEC provides two methods for multi-unit dwelling demand:

1. Standard Method (Article 220.82) -- more conservative
2. Optional Method (Article 220.84) -- more permissive, requires individual metering

Article 220.84 (Optional Method for Multi-Family Dwellings) is used for buildings with individual metering where the number of units exceeds a threshold.

Method: Article 220.84 demand factors

For dwelling units with all-electric cooking and heating:

Each unit has 8kW = 8 kVA (at unity pf for simplicity):

Per unit:
  First 3 kVA at 100% = 3.0 kVA
  Remaining 5 kVA at 35% = 1.75 kVA
  Per unit demand = 4.75 kVA

Diversified dwelling demand = 100 x 4.75 = 475 kVA

NEC also applies an additional demand factor for the number of units:

From Table 220.84: For 100 dwelling units, the demand factor applied to the total is approximately 28% for the variable portion:

Actually, let me recalculate using the correct NEC 220.84 method:

Total connected load per unit = 8 kVA
Total for 100 units = 800 kVA

NEC 220.84 demand factors:
  100 units at 8 kVA each:
  First 3 kVA x 100 = 300 kVA at 100% = 300 kVA
  Next 117 kVA at 35% = 41 kVA (3 to 120 kVA range)
  Next 117 kVA at 25% = 29 kVA (120 to 237 kVA range)
  Remainder: 266 kVA at 20% = 53 kVA

Wait -- the NEC Optional Method aggregates differently. Let me use the correct procedure.

NEC Article 220.84 for 100 dwelling units, each at 8 kVA:

Step 1: Calculate total connected load = 100 x 8 kVA = 800 kVA

Step 2: Apply demand factor from Table 220.84:

• For 100 dwelling units: the table provides a demand factor based on unit count
• At 100 units: approximately 28% of the total load beyond the first portion

Using the simpler formulation:

For 100 units, NEC Optional Method net demand factor ~ 40-45% of installed load
Diversified demand = 800 x 0.40 = 320 kVA (low estimate)
or
Diversified demand = 800 x 0.45 = 360 kVA (high estimate)

Using the detailed calculation:
Demand = 100 x [3 + (5 x 0.35)] = 100 x 4.75 = 475 kVA

However, NEC 220.84 also provides a FURTHER reduction for the aggregate of units:

For 100 dwelling units, Table 220.84 applies a whole-building demand factor of approximately 0.58 (42% reduction) to the aggregate dwelling load:

Adjusted dwelling demand = 475 x 0.58 = 275.5 kVA

Adding common services:

Common services = 60.4 kVA

Total maximum demand = 275.5 + 60.4 = 335.9 kVA

To illustrate the NEC range, let us use the Standard Method (Article 220.82) as well:

Standard Method:
  General lighting: 100 units x 3 VA/ft2 x 800 ft2 = 240 kVA (at 100%)
  Small appliance + laundry: 100 x 3 kVA = 300 kVA
  Apply Table 220.42 demand factors:
    First 3 kVA at 100% = 3 kVA
    3-120 kVA at 35% = 41 kVA
    Over 120 kVA at 25% = 105 kVA
  Cooking: 100 ranges at 8 kW = use Table 220.55 Column C: demand = 47 kW
  A/C and heat: larger of heating or cooling

  This method yields approximately 400-500 kVA depending on specific appliance breakdown

For our comparison, we will use the Optional Method result: 336 kVA.

NEC transformer selection: 500 kVA (standard US transformer size; US utilities typically offer 167, 250, 333, 500, 750, 1000 kVA)

Effective diversity factor for dwellings: 275.5 / 800 = 34.4%

---

IEC 60364 (Annex A / National Annexes)

IEC 60364 provides diversity guidance in Annex A (informative), but most countries using IEC add their own national annexes with specific diversity factors. The base IEC approach is more conservative than most national adaptations.

Method: IEC 60364-8-1, Annex A

For residential buildings, IEC provides a general diversity factor curve:

Note: These are the base IEC values. Countries with high cooling loads (Middle East, Southeast Asia) use higher factors. Countries with temperate climates (Western Europe) use lower factors. The IEC values represent a "middle of the road" international consensus.

Calculation:

Individual unit demand = 8 kVA
Diversified dwelling demand = 100 x 8 x 0.35 = 280 kVA

Common services = 60.4 kVA (diversity factor 1.0 for safety-critical services)

Total maximum demand = 280 + 60.4 = 340.4 kVA

IEC transformer selection: 400 kVA (IEC standard sizes: 100, 160, 250, 315, 400, 500, 630, 800, 1000 kVA)

Effective diversity factor for dwellings: 280 / 800 = 35.0%

---

But What About Hot Climates?

The IEC base values assume temperate conditions. Many countries that use IEC 60364 are in hot climates where air conditioning dominates the load profile. National annexes in these regions specify higher diversity factors:

For the UAE (DEWA), the same building requires:

Diversified dwelling demand = 100 x 8 x 0.60 = 480 kVA
Total = 480 + 60.4 = 540.4 kVA

UAE transformer selection: 630 kVA

For Germany (VDE 0100):

Diversified dwelling demand = 100 x 8 x 0.30 = 240 kVA
Total = 240 + 60.4 = 300.4 kVA

German transformer selection: 315 kVA

The same IEC-based standard, the same building, a factor-of-two difference in transformer size between Dubai and Berlin.

---

Summary Comparison Table

The gap between the highest (AS/NZS, 500 kVA) and lowest (BS 7671, 315 kVA) is 185 kVA -- nearly 60% larger.

---

---

The EV Charging Multiplier

Electric vehicle charging changes the demand profile fundamentally. A 7kW Mode 2 charger per apartment adds 700kW of installed load to the building. What diversity factors should apply?

Without EV charging:

With unmanaged EV charging (worst case):

The transformer doubles in every case. For a building designed in 2020 without EV provisions, retrofitting 100 EV chargers requires a new transformer -- a $50,000-$100,000 cost that could have been avoided by designing for EV from day one.

---

Cost Impact Analysis

The difference in transformer sizing cascades through the entire supply infrastructure:

The difference between the BS 7671 design (315 kVA) and the AS/NZS design (500 kVA) is approximately $31,000. On a 100-unit apartment project costing $50-80 million, this is a rounding error -- but it is still $31,000 that could be spent on something else if the diversity factor is accurate.

The risk of undersizing is far greater than the cost of oversizing. A transformer that overloads loses lifespan (approximately 2x for every 6C above rated temperature), and replacement requires months of lead time and major disruption to residents.

---

Practical Implications for Multi-Jurisdiction Engineers

1. Always use the diversity factors from the standard applicable to your jurisdiction. Mixing diversity factors from different standards is a compliance violation and an engineering error.

2. For international projects, use local utility requirements as the primary guide. The distribution network operator (DNO/utility) usually specifies the ADMD they require, which supersedes the wiring standard. Always check with the local utility before finalising transformer sizing.

3. Climate is the single biggest variable. Hot-climate countries need higher diversity factors (more simultaneous cooling). Temperate climates allow lower factors. A "standard" IEC diversity factor is insufficient for Dubai or Singapore.

4. Design for EV charging from day one. Regardless of which standard applies, retrofitting EV charging capacity is far more expensive than including it in the original design. Allow 50-100% of the EV load as additional transformer capacity.

5. Metering data beats table values. If similar buildings exist in the same area, request actual metering data from the utility. Real ADMD data for a comparable building is more accurate than any standard's table.

6. Consider future electrification. Gas-to-electric conversions (heat pumps replacing gas boilers in the UK, induction cooktops replacing gas in Australia) will increase ADMD. Design the supply infrastructure for the building's 30-year life, not its day-one load.

7. The transformer is the cheapest part of getting it wrong. An undersized supply means the utility must upgrade the local network -- new substations, new feeders, road works. This can cost $500,000+ and take 2 years. The transformer upgrade is the easy part.

---

Related Resources

• Maximum Demand: The 20-Unit Apartment Block -- Smaller building, same diversity divergence
• Maximum Demand: Why Adding Up All Your CBs Overestimates -- The diversity factor trap explained
• Auckland CBD Crisis: Maximum Demand Calculation -- When diversity assumptions fail at city scale
• Transformer Sizing: Beyond the kVA Rating -- Why transformer selection is about more than demand
• Maximum Demand Calculator -- Calculate diversified demand for your building